Gretchen Rubin

The Penalty for a Bad Habit? The Bad Habit.

The Penalty for a Bad Habit? The Bad Habit.

Assay: One of the things that strikes me most, in my study of habits, is the poetic justice of habits.

As you may (or may not) remember from your high school English class, "poetic justice" is when a punishment fits the crime. In Dante’s vision of the Ninth Circle of Hell, a fiend punishes the sowers of discord and schism by continually splitting apart their bodies. Or a criminal sets an illegal trap, but then gets caught in the trap himself.

There's a real poetic justice about habits. The reward for a good habit...is the good habit. As Ralph Waldo Emerson wrote, in "New England Reformers," "The reward of a thing well done is to have done it."

Even more striking is the poetic justice of bad habits. As a friend said to me, “I feel too anxious to tackle my bad habits, but my bad habits are what make me anxious.” One survey found that some women who worry about their finances use “retail therapy” to feel better—they shop in order to cope with their anxiety. Gamblers who worry about money distract themselves by gambling. When procrastinators fall behind, working on the task makes them so anxious that they have to stop working in order to feel better; as someone wrote on my blog, “I feel anxious because I’m not getting anything done, so I get a massage to feel better. But I don’t get anything done, because I’m busy with things like getting a massage.”

In his memoir about his weight loss, Never Goin’ Back, Al Roker describes the morning he promised his dying father that he’d lose weight. Later that day, he recalls, “I was so upset about my promise to lose weight, in fact, that I had two grilled cheese and bacon sandwiches for lunch.”

Although some people assume that strong feelings of guilt or shame act as safeguards to help people stick to good habits, the opposite is true.

Guilt and shame about a bad habit can make people feel so bad that they seek to make themselves feel better—by indulging in the very habit that made them feel bad in the first place. Which is where the poetic justice kicks in.

By contrast, people who feel less guilt and who show compassion toward themselves in the face of failure are better able to regain self-control -- and therefore, they're able to resist indulging in the bad habits that make them feel bad.

Instead of viewing our stumbles as evidence that we’re weak or undisciplined or lazy, we can see our stumbles as part of the habit-formation process. Telling ourselves things like, “It happens,” “We’ve all done it,” “I’ll act differently next time,” or “What I do most days matters more than what I do once in a while” helps us learn from a misstep, and do better next time.  That kind of self-encouragement is a greater safeguard than self-blame.

Do you ever find yourself feeling worse because of a habit that's meant to help you feel better? (Along the same lines, here are six mood boosters that often do more harm than good.)

----------

Want more like this? Sign up for my newsletter and I'll send you a free chapter from my newest New York Times bestseller.
Click here to subscribe. 

icon emailNewsletterLight

One Last Thing

Interested in happiness, habits, and human nature?

Sign up to get my free monthly newsletter. It highlights the best material from here and the Facebook Page.

Sign Up Now
\

\n","excerpt":"\

Assay: One of the things that strikes me most, in my study of habits, is the poetic justice of habits. As you may (or may not) remember from your high school English class, “poetic justice” is when a punishment fits the crime. In Dante’s vision of the Ninth Circle of Hell, a fiend punishes the […]\

\n","terms":[2255,5,403,2269],"metadata":{"primaryCategory":"","readerPoll":"","diveInto":{"module":{"title":"Dive Into The Blog","moreLabel":"","moreLink":""},"items":[{"title":"Top 100","description":"Start here with the 100 most read posts of all-time.","link":"/top-100/","icon":"top100"},{"title":"Quizzes","description":"Everyone likes a good quiz. Learn about yourself here.","link":"/category/quizzes/","icon":"quizzes"},{"title":"Tips","description":"Get good tips here.","link":"/category/tips/","icon":"tips"},{"title":"The Archive","description":"Find any post based on month, year, or topic.","link":"/blog/","icon":"archive"},{"title":"Subscribe","description":"Get my free “Moments of Happiness” quotes newsletter.","link":"/#newsletter","icon":"emailNewsletterLight"},{"title":"Join The Book Club","description":"Get monthly book recommendations from me.","link":"/#newsletter","icon":"book"}]},"morePosts":{"postIds":[45323,36874,43466,43985],"labels":["Up Next","More in Assay","More in habits","More in Uncategorized"]},"oneLastThing":{"id":44068,"title":"Interested in happiness, habits, and human nature?","content":"\

Sign up to get my free monthly newsletter. It highlights the best material from here and the Facebook Page.\

\n","icon":"emailNewsletterLight","buttonText":"Sign Up Now","buttonUrl":"/#newsletter"},"dateGmt":"2014-08-11T18:18:33","guid":{"rendered":"http://www.gretchenrubin.com/?p=31733"},"modifiedGmt":"2015-11-05T22:00:32","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https://api.gretchenrubin.com/2014/08/the-penalty-for-a-bad-habit-the-bad-habit/","featuredMedia":31743,"commentStatus":"open","pingStatus":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":[],"unixTimestamp":1407781113,"featuredImage":"https://i1.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/scales-of-justice.jpg","disqus":{"disqusUrl":"https://api.gretchenrubin.com/2014/08/the-penalty-for-a-bad-habit-the-bad-habit/","disqusIdentifier":"31733 http://gretchenrubin.com/?p=31733","disqusContainerId":"disqus_thread","disqusShortname":"thehappinessprojectblog","disqusTitle":"The Penalty for a Bad Habit? The Bad Habit."},"postTypeObject":{"name":"post","label":"Posts","labels":{"name":"Posts","singularName":"Post","addNew":"Add New","addNewItem":"Add New Post","editItem":"Edit Post","newItem":"New Post","viewItem":"View Post","viewItems":"View Posts","searchItems":"Search Posts","notFound":"No posts found.","notFoundInTrash":"No posts found in Trash.","parentItemColon":null,"allItems":"All Posts","archives":"Post Archives","attributes":"Post Attributes","insertIntoItem":"Insert into post","uploadedToThisItem":"Uploaded to this post","featuredImage":"Featured Image","setFeaturedImage":"Set featured image","removeFeaturedImage":"Remove featured image","useFeaturedImage":"Use as featured image","filterItemsList":"Filter posts list","itemsListNavigation":"Posts list navigation","itemsList":"Posts list","menuName":"Posts","nameAdminBar":"Post"},"description":"","public":true,"hierarchical":false,"excludeFromSearch":false,"publiclyQueryable":true,"showUi":true,"showInMenu":true,"showInNavMenus":true,"showInAdminBar":true,"menuPosition":5,"menuIcon":null,"capabilityType":"post","mapMetaCap":true,"registerMetaBoxCb":null,"taxonomies":[],"hasArchive":false,"queryVar":false,"canExport":true,"deleteWithUser":true,"builtin":true,"editLink":"post.php?post=%d","cap":{"editPost":"edit_post","readPost":"read_post","deletePost":"delete_post","editPosts":"edit_posts","editOthersPosts":"edit_others_posts","publishPosts":"publish_posts","readPrivatePosts":"read_private_posts","read":"read","deletePosts":"delete_posts","deletePrivatePosts":"delete_private_posts","deletePublishedPosts":"delete_published_posts","deleteOthersPosts":"delete_others_posts","editPrivatePosts":"edit_private_posts","editPublishedPosts":"edit_published_posts","createPosts":"edit_posts"},"rewrite":false,"showInRest":true,"restBase":"posts","restControllerClass":"WP_REST_Posts_Controller"}}}},"idBySlug":{"the-penalty-for-a-bad-habit-the-bad-habit":31733}},"product":{"byId":{},"idBySlug":{}},"quote":{"byId":{},"idBySlug":{}},"resource":{"byId":{},"idBySlug":{}},"video":{"byId":{},"idBySlug":{}}},"term":{"category":{"byId":{"2255":{"id":2255,"name":"Habits","slug":"habits","taxonomy":"category"}},"idBySlug":{"habits":2255}},"post_tag":{"byId":{"5":{"id":5,"name":"Assay","slug":"assay","taxonomy":"post_tag"},"403":{"id":403,"name":"habits","slug":"habits","taxonomy":"post_tag"},"2269":{"id":2269,"name":"Uncategorized","slug":"uncategorized","taxonomy":"post_tag"}},"idBySlug":{"assay":5,"habits":403,"uncategorized":2269}},"podcast":{"byId":{},"idBySlug":{}},"resource-type":{"byId":{},"idBySlug":{}}},"latest":{"pagination":{"perPage":10,"currentPage":1,"totalPages":null,"total":null},"refs":[],"loading":false},"menu":{"header":[{"id":44579,"parentId":0,"type":"post_type","label":"About","url":"/about/biography/","classes":[""],"slug":"biography","postType":"page"},{"id":44195,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Books","url":"/books/","classes":[""]},{"id":44196,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Podcasts","url":"/podcasts/","classes":[""]},{"id":44197,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Blog","url":"/blog/","classes":[""]},{"id":44198,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Shop","url":"/shop/","classes":[""]}],"popOut":[{"id":44342,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Home","url":"/","classes":[""]},{"id":44343,"parentId":0,"type":"post_type","label":"About","url":"/about/","classes":[""],"slug":"about","postType":"page"},{"id":44344,"parentId":44343,"type":"post_type","label":"Biography","url":"/about/biography/","classes":[""],"slug":"biography","postType":"page"},{"id":44347,"parentId":44343,"type":"post_type","label":"For the Press","url":"/about/for-the-press/","classes":[""],"slug":"for-the-press","postType":"page"},{"id":44348,"parentId":44343,"type":"post_type","label":"Manifesto","url":"/about/manifesto/","classes":[""],"slug":"manifesto","postType":"page"},{"id":44346,"parentId":44343,"type":"post_type","label":"Live Events","url":"/about/live-events/","classes":[""],"slug":"live-events","postType":"page"},{"id":45583,"parentId":44343,"type":"post_type","label":"Live Video","url":"/about/live-video/","classes":[""],"slug":"live-video","postType":"page"},{"id":44345,"parentId":44343,"type":"post_type","label":"Contact","url":"/about/contact/","classes":[""],"slug":"contact","postType":"page"},{"id":44349,"parentId":0,"type":"post_type","label":"Books","url":"/books/","classes":[""],"slug":"books","postType":"page"},{"id":45584,"parentId":44349,"type":"custom","label":"All Books","url":"/books/","classes":[""]},{"id":44702,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"The Four Tendencies","url":"/book/the-four-tendencies/","classes":["new"],"slug":"the-four-tendencies","postType":"book"},{"id":44696,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"Better Than Before","url":"/book/better-than-before/","classes":[""],"slug":"better-than-before","postType":"book"},{"id":44699,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"Happier at Home","url":"/book/happier-at-home/","classes":[""],"slug":"happier-at-home","postType":"book"},{"id":44703,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"The Happiness Project","url":"/book/the-happiness-project/","classes":[""],"slug":"the-happiness-project","postType":"book"},{"id":44698,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"Forty Ways to Look at Winston Churchill","url":"/book/forty-ways-to-look-at-winston-churchill/","classes":[""],"slug":"forty-ways-to-look-at-winston-churchill","postType":"book"},{"id":44697,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"Forty Ways to Look at JFK","url":"/book/forty-ways-to-look-at-jfk/","classes":[""],"slug":"forty-ways-to-look-at-jfk","postType":"book"},{"id":44700,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"Power Money Fame Sex","url":"/book/power-money-fame-sex/","classes":[""],"slug":"power-money-fame-sex","postType":"book"},{"id":44701,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"Profane Waste","url":"/book/profane-waste/","classes":[""],"slug":"profane-waste","postType":"book"},{"id":44704,"parentId":44349,"type":"post_type","label":"The Restatement of Love","url":"/book/the-restatement-of-love/","classes":[""],"slug":"the-restatement-of-love","postType":"book"},{"id":44353,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Podcasts","url":"/podcasts/","classes":[""]},{"id":44354,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Blog","url":"/blog/","classes":[""]},{"id":45585,"parentId":44354,"type":"custom","label":"All Posts","url":"/blog/","classes":[""]},{"id":45592,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Quizzes","url":"/category/quizzes/","classes":[""],"slug":"quizzes","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":44707,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Tips","url":"/tag/tips/","classes":[""],"slug":"tips","taxonomy":"post_tag"},{"id":44708,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Happiness","url":"/tag/happiness-2/","classes":[""],"slug":"happiness-2","taxonomy":"post_tag"},{"id":45587,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Health","url":"/category/health/","classes":[""],"slug":"health","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45590,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Relationships","url":"/category/relationships/","classes":[""],"slug":"relationships","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45593,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Habits","url":"/category/habits/","classes":[""],"slug":"habits","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45588,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Mindfulness","url":"/category/mindfulness/","classes":[""],"slug":"mindfulness","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45589,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Productivity","url":"/category/productivity/","classes":[""],"slug":"productivity","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45591,"parentId":44354,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Self-Knowledge","url":"/category/self-knowledge/","classes":[""],"slug":"self-knowledge","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45284,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Shop","url":"/shop/","classes":[""]}],"footerLeft":[{"id":45108,"parentId":0,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Quizzes","url":"/category/quizzes/","classes":[""],"slug":"quizzes","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45109,"parentId":0,"type":"taxonomy","label":"Tips","url":"/category/tips/","classes":[""],"slug":"tips","taxonomy":"category"},{"id":45110,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Videos","url":"/video-gallery/","classes":[""]},{"id":45639,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Collections","url":"/collection/","classes":[""]},{"id":45640,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Galleries","url":"/gallery/","classes":[""]},{"id":45111,"parentId":0,"type":"post_type","label":"Secrets of Adulthood","url":"/gallery/secrets-of-adulthood/","classes":[""],"slug":"secrets-of-adulthood","postType":"gallery"},{"id":44200,"parentId":0,"type":"post_type","label":"Short Bio","url":"/about/biography/","classes":[""],"slug":"biography","postType":"page"},{"id":44201,"parentId":0,"type":"post_type","label":"Contact Gretchen Rubin","url":"/about/contact/","classes":[""],"slug":"contact","postType":"page"}],"footerCenter":[{"id":44202,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"All Resources","url":"https://gretchenrubin.com/resources/","classes":[""]},{"id":45580,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Book Downloads","url":"/resources/","classes":[""]},{"id":45581,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Podcast Downloads","url":"/resources/","classes":[""]},{"id":45582,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Other Downloads","url":"/resources/","classes":[""]}],"footerRight":[{"id":44481,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Newsletter","url":"#newsletter","classes":[""]},{"id":44482,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Facebook","url":"https://www.facebook.com/GretchenRubin","classes":[""]},{"id":44483,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Twitter","url":"https://twitter.com/gretchenrubin","classes":[""]},{"id":44484,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"LinkedIn","url":"https://www.linkedin.com/in/gretchenrubin","classes":[""]},{"id":44485,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Pinterest","url":"https://www.pinterest.com/gretchenrubin/","classes":[""]},{"id":44486,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"YouTube","url":"https://www.youtube.com/user/GretchenRubinNY","classes":[""]},{"id":44487,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Instagram","url":"https://instagram.com/gretchenrubin","classes":[""]},{"id":44488,"parentId":0,"type":"custom","label":"Feedburner","url":"https://feeds.feedburner.com/TheHappinessProject","classes":[""]}]},"ui":{"headerSticky":false},"poll":{"byPostId":{},"loading":false},"instagram":{"loading":false,"items":[]},"author":{"2":{"id":2,"description":"","slug":"gretchenrubin","avatarMap":{"24":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/e325d398e969be5d3cf901d3d47ba296?s=24&d=mm&r=g","48":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/e325d398e969be5d3cf901d3d47ba296?s=48&d=mm&r=g","96":"https://secure.gravatar.com/avatar/e325d398e969be5d3cf901d3d47ba296?s=96&d=mm&r=g"}}},"contentType":{"book":{"id":"book","slug":"book"},"collection":{"id":"collection","slug":"collection"},"facebook-live":{"id":"facebook-live","slug":"facebook-live"},"gallery":{"id":"gallery","slug":"gallery"},"one-last-thing":{"id":"one-last-thing","slug":"one-last-thing"},"page":{"id":"page","slug":"page"},"podcast-episode":{"id":"podcast-episode","slug":"podcast-episode"},"post":{"id":"post","slug":"post"},"product":{"id":"product","slug":"product"},"quote":{"id":"quote","slug":"quote"},"resource":{"id":"resource","slug":"resource"},"video":{"id":"video","slug":"video"}},"landingPage":{"settings":{"id":"settings"},"homepage":{"id":"homepage"},"top-100":{"id":"top-100"},"search":{"id":"search"},"blog":{"id":"blog"},"term_archive":{"id":"term_archive"},"books":{"id":"books"},"four_tendencies":{"id":"four_tendencies"},"podcasts":{"id":"podcasts"},"shop":{"id":"shop"},"checkout":{"id":"checkout"},"video_gallery":{"id":"video_gallery"},"resources":{"id":"resources"}},"info":{"title":{"id":"title","value":"Gretchen Rubin"}},"taxonomy":{"category":{"id":"category","slug":"category"},"post_tag":{"id":"post_tag","slug":"post_tag"},"podcast":{"id":"podcast","slug":"podcast"},"resource-type":{"id":"resource-type","slug":"resource-type"}},"footer":{"text":["Email Gretchen: \[email protected]\","© 2017 Gretchen Rubin. All rights reserved."],"books":[{"title":"The Four Tendencies","imageUrl":"https://i1.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/four-tendencies.jpg","slug":"/book/the-four-tendencies/"},{"title":"Better Than Before","imageUrl":"https://i1.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/better-than-before.jpg","slug":"/book/better-than-before/"},{"title":"Happier at Home","imageUrl":"https://i1.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/HappierAtHomePaperback.jpg","slug":"/book/happier-at-home/"},{"title":"The Happiness Project","imageUrl":"https://i1.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/the-happiness-project.jpg","slug":"/book/the-happiness-project/"},{"title":"Forty Ways to Look at JFK","imageUrl":"https://i2.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Forty-Ways-to-Look-at-JFK.jpg","slug":"/book/forty-ways-to-look-at-jfk/"},{"title":"Forty Ways to Look at Winston Churchill","imageUrl":"https://i2.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2004/05/Forty-Ways-to-Look-at-Winston-Churchill.jpg","slug":"/book/forty-ways-to-look-at-winston-churchill/"},{"title":"Power Money Fame Sex","imageUrl":"https://i2.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/Power-Money-Fame-Sex.jpg","slug":"/book/power-money-fame-sex/"},{"title":"Profane Waste","imageUrl":"https://i0.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/profane-waste.jpg","slug":"/book/profane-waste/"},{"title":"The Restatement of Love","imageUrl":"https://i1.wp.com/api.gretchenrubin.com/wp-content/uploads/1994/08/the-yale-law-review-gretchen-rubin.png","slug":"/book/the-restatement-of-love/"}]},"redirect":{"/about/":"/about/biography/","/book/the-four-tendencies/":"/books/the-four-tendencies/intro/","/book/better-than-before/":"/books/better-than-before/about-the-book/","/book/happier-at-home/":"/books/happier-at-home/about-the-book/","/book/the-happiness-project/":"/books/the-happiness-project/about-the-book/","/book/profane-waste/":"/books/profane-waste/about-the-book/","/book/forty-ways-to-look-at-jfk/":"/books/forty-ways-to-look-at-jfk/about-the-book/","/book/forty-ways-to-look-at-winston-churchill/":"/books/forty-ways-to-look-at-winston-churchill/about-the-book/","/book/power-money-fame-sex/":"/books/power-money-fame-sex/about-the-book/","/book/the-restatement-of-love/":"/books/the-restatement-of-love/about-the-article/","/4tbonus/":"/books/the-four-tendencies/intro/","/podcast/":"/podcasts/","/quizzes/":"/category/quizzes/","/get-started/want-to-be-happier-try-one-of-these-21-day-happiness-projects/":"/21-day-projects/"},"newsletter":{"signedUp":false,"lists":[],"loading":true,"seen":false},"video":{},"player":{"podcastId":null,"seek":false,"duration":0,"currentTime":0,"volume":0.5,"playing":false,"visible":false},"resource":{}};